Beyond Growth: What Makes Industrialization Real Progress?

16 Min Read
Listen to this article
Hossein Latifi
8 articles

Normal
0
false

false
false
false

EN-US
X-NONE
AR-SA

/* Style Definitions */
table.MsoNormalTable
{mso-style-name:”Table Normal”;
mso-tstyle-rowband-size:0;
mso-tstyle-colband-size:0;
mso-style-noshow:yes;
mso-style-priority:99;
mso-style-parent:””;
mso-padding-alt:0cm 5.4pt 0cm 5.4pt;
mso-para-margin-top:0cm;
mso-para-margin-right:0cm;
mso-para-margin-bottom:10.0pt;
mso-para-margin-left:0cm;
text-align:justify;
line-height:115%;
mso-pagination:widow-orphan;
font-size:14.0pt;
font-family:”Calibri”,sans-serif;
mso-bidi-font-family:”B Badr”;
mso-font-kerning:1.0pt;
mso-ligatures:standardcontextual;}

Introduction

A
factory opens, production rises, and a region gains jobs. By several familiar
measures, the project is a success. But suppose it also draws more water than
the local supply can replenish, exposes workers to long-term health risks, or
leaves nearby communities to pay for pollution they did little to produce. The
gains are real. So are the losses. Whether the project counts as progress
depends on which effects we measure, whose experience we consider, and how far
ahead we look.

That
distinction is at the heart of my account of responsible industrialization.
Engineering and the natural sciences can tell us what is technically possible.
Economics can help us understand costs, incentives, and investment. But even a
technically sound and profitable project leaves other questions open: What
should industry be for? Who should benefit? What harms are unacceptable, even
when a project promises substantial returns? And what obligations do we have to
people who will live with the consequences long after the original decisions
have been made?

I
approach these questions through three concepts from Islamic thought: taskhīr,
the availability of nature for human benefit; istiʿmār, the habitation and
cultivation of the earth; and tadbīr, the prudent ordering of action with
attention to its consequences. Together, they explain why the ability to
produce more is worth developing—and why it is not enough.

Technology,
industrialization, and development are not the same thing

Technology
gives people the means to act: tools, materials, knowledge, and techniques that
make particular tasks possible. Industrialization is a wider transformation. It
happens when societies build the skills, infrastructure, organizations, and
relationships needed to sustain production. A country may import sophisticated
machinery and use it extensively without acquiring the capacity to design,
repair, or improve it. It may also have numerous factories without the networks
of suppliers, training institutions, and financing that allow industry to take
root.

Development
asks a different question: What does this productive capacity do for collective
life? Higher output and rising gross domestic product tell us something
important, but they cannot establish whether poverty is falling, whether people
have access to secure and dignified work, or whether the benefits will last. As
development economist Dudley Seers argued, strong economic growth is a poor
basis for declaring success if poverty, unemployment, and inequality persist or
worsen.

The
distinction matters because each achievement can be mistaken for the next.
Buying machinery can look like building an industrial economy. Expanding an
industrial economy can look like improving people’s lives. Yet each step raises
questions the previous one cannot answer. Industrialization is a major
historical route to development, not a guarantee of it or a single path every
society must follow. What matters is not only how much an economy produces, but
also who benefits, what institutions make those benefits durable, and what
costs are left out of the account.

Taskhīr: Using
nature without assuming unlimited control

The
Qurʾanic concept of taskhīr describes aspects of creation as made available for
human benefit. The Qurʾan speaks in this way about rivers and the sea, ships
and livestock, and even the sun, moon, and succession of night and day. These
examples do not all imply the same relationship. People can steer ships and
direct animals, but they benefit from daylight and seasonal cycles without
commanding them. Something can be available to us without being ours to control.

This
distinction offers a way to think about technology without making mastery over
nature its defining ambition. A craftsperson works with properties they did not
create. An engineer may direct a natural process, but only by understanding the
conditions under which it operates. The ability to work with those conditions
is a real accomplishment. In my reading, it is also a reminder of dependence:
human ingenuity can transform what is given, but it does not originate the
natural order on which that ingenuity relies.

Within
this Islamic account, nature belongs to an order that precedes human purposes.
Its significance is not exhausted by what people can extract from it.
Recognizing this need not discourage invention. It does, however, separate a
technical judgment from a moral one. The fact that a process works tells us
what people can do; it does not tell us whether they should do it, for whose
benefit, or at whose expense. Taskhīr makes room for productive agency without
turning it into an unconditional right to exploit.

Istiʿmār:
Building the capacity to sustain collective life

In
Qurʾan 11:61, human beings are described as brought forth from the earth and
settled in it or called to cultivate it. Classical commentators differ over the
emphasis. Some understand the verse primarily in terms of habitation: the earth
is where human beings are enabled to live. Others stress the active work of
cultivation, including farming, planting trees, building dwellings, and
organizing the surroundings that make settled life possible.

I
would like to draw on this constructive reading without claiming that the verse
is literally about modern industry. The connection is that industrialization,
like cultivation, takes more than an isolated act of invention. It involves
building capacities that people can use and develop over time. A factory
depends on trained workers, reliable infrastructure, suppliers, finance, and
rules that govern relationships among them. Installing machinery is one event;
building the ability to operate, maintain, adapt, and improve it is a longer
social undertaking.

 

Industry
can therefore be a form of constructive cultivation, but only under certain
conditions. The Qurʾanic account of Thamūd places impressive skill in carving
dwellings into mountains alongside a warning against spreading corruption
(7:74). The juxtaposition matters: the ability to transform an environment is
not proof that the transformation is good. An industry can develop skills and
provide goods people need while still damaging farmland, drawing down water
supplies, or creating unsafe conditions for workers. Calling such activity
cultivation requires looking at what it builds and what it leaves less capable
of sustaining life.

Tadbīr: Looking
beyond the immediate return

If
taskhīr concerns what is available to human agency, and istiʿmār concerns what
that agency can construct, tadbīr asks how action should be ordered in light of
what follows. The scholar al-Rāghib al-Iṣfahānī defines the term as reflection
on the outcomes of affairs. A prophetic Hadith expresses a similar principle:
before undertaking an action, consider where it is likely to lead.

For
industry, this means widening the field of assessment. How much water will a
plant use, and can the source replenish itself at that rate? What happens when
its emissions are added to those of other plants nearby? How will repeated
exposure affect workers’ health? If damage emerges after years of operation,
who will be responsible? A project can look attractive when evaluated on its
own, over a short period, and from the investor’s point of view. Change the
time frame or include the people who will bear the costs, and the judgment may
change.

Foresight
is not the same as certainty. Some consequences cannot be known in advance, and
ethical principles cannot tell us how quickly an aquifer replenishes or what
level of exposure is dangerous. Those questions require empirical research. The
contribution of tadbīr is to make such evidence relevant to the decision from
the outset. It also makes accountability important after a project is approved:
institutions need ways to monitor actual effects, respond to new evidence, and
prevent foreseeable costs from being passed on to communities or future
generations.

When growth
damages the conditions that make it possible

A
shared limit runs through all three concepts: the Qurʾanic prohibition of
corruption, or fasād. The term is broader than environmental damage, just as
the injunction not to cause corruption after the earth has been set right
(7:56) is not a just a modern environmental regulation.

One
especially vivid passage describes someone who spreads corruption and destroys
“crops and offspring” (2:205). The image brings together the means of
sustenance and the continuity of life. This offers an ethical criterion for
evaluating practices that damage the foundations on which human and non-human
life depend. Another passage, which links corruption on land and sea to what
people’s hands have earned (30:41), reinforces the point that human conduct can
degrade those conditions—and that harmful conduct can be reconsidered.

Consider
a plant that brings jobs and affordable goods but pollutes water used by
households and farms downstream. The task is not to deny the gains. It is to
account for both sides of the decision rather than count one as growth and
leave the other to someone else. That includes asking whether the harm can be
prevented, whether alternatives exist, whose rights are at stake, and who has
the power to demand a remedy. An industry that undermines the conditions on
which its workers, neighbors, or successors depend may be expanding while
weakening its own foundations.

What the
humanities and social sciences bring to industry

This
study contrasts several ways of thinking about the humanities and social
sciences. One treats them mainly as tools for improving efficiency and managing
workplace conflict. Another sees them as central to building the trust, laws,
and institutions on which industrial activity depends. Other approaches
emphasize their role in exposing exploitation, setting public priorities, or
questioning the assumptions about human beings and nature that technological
systems embody. The difference is not simply whether industry needs these
disciplines; it is whether they help decide what industry is meant to achieve.

My
argument is that they should be involved before the goals of a project are
treated as settled. Philosophy and theology can clarify what is meant by human
flourishing and why nature matters beyond its market value. Ethics can ask
whether benefits and harms are fairly distributed. Law and political science
can examine how responsibilities become enforceable, who has a voice in
decisions, and what happens when safeguards fail. Economics and sociology can
show how incentives and unequal bargaining power shape outcomes. History can
reveal why an industrial strategy that succeeded in one place may not work in
another.

None
of these contributions replaces technical expertise. The move from a Qurʾanic
concept to a decision about a particular industry requires interpretation,
knowledge of local conditions, and evidence about available options. A
pollution study can establish the extent of a problem; it cannot by itself
decide who should bear the cost of prevention. An ethical principle can clarify
who deserves protection; it cannot determine which engineering measure will
provide it. Responsible industrialization depends on bringing those judgments
together.

A better test
of progress

Market
competition can encourage firms to innovate, reduce costs, and find better ways
to produce. What it cannot do on its own is establish which ends are worth
pursuing or ensure that all costs appear in the price of a product. Where
oversight is weak, a firm may remain competitive partly because workers,
surrounding communities, or future generations absorb costs that its accounts
do not show. The point is not to reject competition, but to recognize what
foresight and public accountability must add to it.

 

I
need to connect the framework to Iranian discussions of pīshraft, or
normatively desirable progress, and to Islamic accounts of justice grounded in
the order of creation. These connections open a wider conversation about what
makes development worth pursuing. They do not change the practical test: an
industrial achievement must be judged in light of what it enables and what it
preserves.

Return,
then, to the factory that brought jobs to its region. Its contribution is not
fully captured by the goods it ships or the wages it pays, though both matter.
It also depends on whether the jobs are safe, whether useful skills and
institutions remain in the community, whether neighbors can hold the plant
accountable, and whether the water and land on which people depend remain
usable. The ultimate question is not simply whether we can produce more. It is
whether what we build leaves people better able to live well, now and in the
future.

Share This Article
Leave a Comment

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *