The Role of the People in the Legitimacy of the System

6 Min Read
Listen to this article

From Government to Governance: Contrasting Liberal and Islamic Public Values

When discussing governance, it must be distinguished from government. Government refers to a ruling body that administers society, striving to manage people’s affairs with the assistance of the private sector. Governance, however, is a paradigm that emerged in the late twentieth century and departs from the traditional top-down perspective; rather, it entails granting the general public and stakeholders a share in the administration of society.

Later, in defining governance, it was posited that the public sector of society is of paramount importance, and both the private sector and the state must align themselves with the general public. To bring this stage to fruition, the concept of public values was debated, asserting that these values should serve as the benchmark. For instance, in liberalism, the central issue is individual liberty to secure one’s own interests, and the state must serve the freedom of the people without restricting it, unless this freedom causes harm to others.

Individualism and capitalism have been the consequences of this perspective, namely liberalism. Here, questions arise, such as whether boundless sexual and economic relations, as well as the freedom of anti-God propaganda, can be accepted in an Islamic society. This foundational perspective highlights the prominent difference between materialistic human ideologies and the Islamic school of thought.

God has ordained that the overarching public value is monotheism (Tawhid), and He has articulated the divinely established mandates, as well as their dos and don’ts, for society. It is precisely these values that create a divergence from contemporary democracy, for in a religious democracy, the principal and overarching value is the realization of the Divine Will.

The Place of God in Islamic Governance

In conventional global governance, people have usurped the place of God and effectively retired Him. In Islamic governance, however, the axis is God, even though the station of humanity is exalted. Man is the vicegerent of God and must assume a divine character; he is accorded the value of vicegerency to the exact extent that he can crystallize divine values within himself.

The innate and natural desires of humanity can generate values. If these values are built strictly upon innate human nature (Fitrah) and a proper balance is established among them, they can serve as the source for producing public values. Therefore, values derived from God and the shared innate nature among humans can constitute the axis of governance throughout the world.

The institution of religion seeks to establish governance as a public endeavor, and there is corroborating evidence for this in the Quran. The Quran demonstrates that the primary structure of society must be founded upon the pious (Muttaqin); that is, a society is democratic when the general public is pious. Thus, the Quran has articulated certain directives concerning the avoidance of mutual oppression, the maintenance of healthy sexual relations, and adherence to contracts and covenants using expressions such as ‘O mankind’ and the like.

Quranic governance does not imply the marginalization of people-based governance; rather, it regulates it. This means that certain addresses are directed at the general public, some at the scholars of society, others at those who believe in monotheism, and yet others specifically at the believers and the pious; these groups must be distinguished from one another.

The Role of the People in the Legitimacy of the System

With this perspective, the Martyred Leader believed that the legitimacy of the government is derived from the people—an understanding he extrapolated from these very Quranic addresses—and that governments serve as representatives of the public will. This is the essence of religious democratic governance.

From the perspective of the Quran, the participation of the people is not limited solely to observing laws and directives—although such adherence is an organic element of the Ummah-Imam system; rather, they must play an active role in the implementation of Islamic rulings. The fact that the government, the parliament, and even the leadership are elected—albeit sometimes indirectly—by the people exemplifies this very participation of the people in governance.

When concepts such as consultation (mushawirah), council (shura), and enjoining good and forbidding wrong (al-amr bi al-ma’ruf and al-nahy an al-munkar) are used in Islamic sources, it implies that God requires people to perform highly active intervention in creating a righteous and transcendent society. In other words, enjoining good and forbidding wrong, consultation, and similar mechanisms are all instruments for cultivating a transcendent society.

Share This Article
Leave a Comment

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *