Allamah Tabatabai introduces Shia mysticism—derived from the Quran and the Sunnah and in complete harmony with jurisprudence and Islamic law (Sharia)—as authentic mysticism. It is a mysticism drawn from religious evidence and cannot be comprehended solely by innate intellect.
“Of course, I validate mysticism, but not the kind that is prevalent among certain Sufi orders of the Sunni denomination, which treats the spiritual path (tariqa) as a counterpart to religious law (sharia), commanding music, singing, dance, and ecstasy, while proclaiming the abrogation of religious obligations. The mysticism derived from the Quran and the Sunnah is a methodology based on the sincerity of servitude, which does not deviate from the regulations of Islamic law by even a hair’s breadth.[1]”
“Given that their (the Sufis’) method of discussion and inquiry into the doctrinal and practical teachings of the Quran and the Sunnah was the general public method, and because they were not trained in the school of the Ahl al-Bayt and had not fully internalized the absolute scientific and spiritual authority of the Ahl al-Bayt, they were unable to derive the method of inner spiritual journey (sayr wa suluk) from religious statements, nor could they receive sufficient directives for the path from the Quran and the Sunnah.
Consequently, in response to their needs during the various stages of the spiritual journey and the different stations of seekers, diverse instructions were issued by the masters of the tariqa, and methods were adopted that had no precedent in Islamic law. Followers of this school (Sufism) believe that the path to human perfection and the attainment of divine truths is exclusively restricted to the tariqa, and that tariqa stands opposite to sharia—meaning a form of ascetic discipline to endure the sharia, such that if one journeys through this path, one attains the Truth. As a result of this practice and belief, the tariqa drifted further and further away from the sharia day by day, to the point where tariqa and sharia came to stand in direct opposition to each other, and the tune of the abrogation of religious duties was raised by some.[2]”
These afflictions, which were mostly prevalent among the Sunni majority, also affected the Shia minority; the unity of the environment reflected this corruption into the midst of the Shia tariqa community as well.
Mysticism and spiritual inclinations have followers not only among monotheistic religions, but even among pagans, in accordance with innate guidance. Now, among the multitude of man-made and artificial forms of mysticism, what are the distinguishing characteristics of Islamic and Shia mysticism?
[1] Hikmat-e Irfani Journal, Scientific-Research Bi-Quarterly, No. 6, p. 36. ↩
[2] Hikmat-e Irfani Journal, Scientific-Research Bi-Quarterly, No. 6, p. 38. ↩




